OntologyProperty talk:Bibo:pages: Difference between revisions
(Created page with 'IMHO this property is insufficient for several reasons: * the comment "The page number in (an edition of) a written work" is not quite clear: does that mean "number of pages"? ...') |
m (moved OntologyProperty talk:PageNumber to OntologyProperty talk:Bibo:pages: see discussion) |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
https://github.com/dbpedia/mappings-tracker/issues/10 | |||
IMHO this property is insufficient for several reasons: | IMHO this property is insufficient for several reasons: | ||
* the comment "The page number in (an edition of) a written work" is not quite clear: | * the comment "The page number in (an edition of) a written work" is not quite clear: does that mean "number of pages"? | ||
* range shouldn't be xsd:integer, e.g. consider the book [http://www.worldcat.org/title/relativity-the-special-theory/oclc/242174 Relativity : the special theory] that has "xiv, 459 pages" | |||
* range shouldn't be xsd:integer, e.g. consider the book | |||
[http://www.worldcat.org/title/relativity-the-special-theory/oclc/242174 Relativity : the special theory] | |||
that has "xiv, 459 pages" | |||
* cannot represent pagination of an article | * cannot represent pagination of an article | ||
| Line 12: | Line 11: | ||
* bibo:pageEnd "Ending page number within a continuous page range." | * bibo:pageEnd "Ending page number within a continuous page range." | ||
* bibo:numPages "The number of pages contained in a document" | * bibo:numPages "The number of pages contained in a document" | ||
--[[User:VladimirAlexiev|VladimirAlexiev]] 16:45, 22 December 2014 (UTC) | |||
--[[User:VladimirAlexiev|VladimirAlexiev]] | Yeah, you are right about the pageNumber property, I didn't give it too much thought and will change it to xsd:string. It is also useful to know, that as far as I know no page numbers are being extracted. In an internet encyclopedia, it is hardly likely that details of written works will be described at so minute a level (unless for indicating sources). However, I use the page numbers property for data to which the DBpedia ontology is serving as a reference model. | ||
If we could incorporate the Bibo model, of course, I would welcome that. | |||
--[[User:GerardKuys]] | |||
I'm still not entirely clear about the purpose "The page number in (an edition of) a written work at which a thought or quote can be found": so is this a property of a thought/quote? Together with the Work that contains the quote? | |||
Re BIBO: we could just use a BIBO property by making an OntologyProperty page with its name. (Modulo rdfs:domain, in case someone decides to load BIBO...) | |||
--[[User:VladimirAlexiev|VladimirAlexiev]] 13:11, 23 December 2014 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 20:44, 16 January 2015
https://github.com/dbpedia/mappings-tracker/issues/10
IMHO this property is insufficient for several reasons:
- the comment "The page number in (an edition of) a written work" is not quite clear: does that mean "number of pages"?
- range shouldn't be xsd:integer, e.g. consider the book Relativity : the special theory that has "xiv, 459 pages"
- cannot represent pagination of an article
Can't we just use the respective BIBO properties?
- bibo:pages "A string of non-contiguous page spans that locate a Document within a Collection. Example: 23-25, 34, 54-56. For continuous page ranges, use the pageStart and pageEnd properties."
- bibo:pageStart "Starting page number within a continuous page range."
- bibo:pageEnd "Ending page number within a continuous page range."
- bibo:numPages "The number of pages contained in a document"
--VladimirAlexiev 16:45, 22 December 2014 (UTC)
Yeah, you are right about the pageNumber property, I didn't give it too much thought and will change it to xsd:string. It is also useful to know, that as far as I know no page numbers are being extracted. In an internet encyclopedia, it is hardly likely that details of written works will be described at so minute a level (unless for indicating sources). However, I use the page numbers property for data to which the DBpedia ontology is serving as a reference model. If we could incorporate the Bibo model, of course, I would welcome that. --User:GerardKuys
I'm still not entirely clear about the purpose "The page number in (an edition of) a written work at which a thought or quote can be found": so is this a property of a thought/quote? Together with the Work that contains the quote?
Re BIBO: we could just use a BIBO property by making an OntologyProperty page with its name. (Modulo rdfs:domain, in case someone decides to load BIBO...) --VladimirAlexiev 13:11, 23 December 2014 (UTC)
